What’s a Good Choice-- Plasma Cutting or Oxy-fuel?

Steel service centers and fabricators looking towards purchasing a new machine often ask this question-- Plasma Cutting or Oxy-fuel? The other frequently posed question is: should a particular part be cut with plasma or oxy-fuel? The confusion is limited to those working with mild steel as oxy-fuel fails to cut an aluminum or stainless plate; and the answer to the debate depends on various factors-- thickness, location, alloy, variety of work, cost, power resources, etc.

Comparing Plasma vs. Oxy-fuel -- Cutting Speed

Based singularly on cutting speed, plasma serves to be faster than an oxy-fuel torch, to an extent of 2.75 inches. The act of using two oxy-fuel torches makes the speed drop back to a thickness of 2 inches. In the comparison of a single plasma torch versus 4 oxy-fuel torches, oxy-fuel wins when it is at 1-1/8 inch and thicker. This shows that:

• A one inch cut-off with respect to plasma holds true if the parts are being cut with at least 4 different oxy-fuel torches at the same time;
• Plasma ranks higher on speed on anything that’s less than 3/4 inch thick, also with 4 oxy-fuel torches versus 260 Amps.

Comparison of Oxy-Fuel and Plasma-- Cost-Per-Inch

After taking all the costs associated with the two processes:

• Plasma: nozzles, shields, retainers, electrodes, baffles, oxygen, electricity, compressed air and torch coolant;
• Oxy-fuel: fuel gas, internal/external nozzles, and oxygen;

studies have shown that an oxy-fuel torch proves less expensive (per inch) than 450 Amp plasma; this is true for anything that’s above 2-5/8 inch of thickness. Cutting with 4 oxy-fuel torches is far less expensive (per inch) until a thickness of 3/4 inch.

Comparing Oxy-Fuel vs. Plasma--Cost-per-Part

When different part-sizes (with varying numbers of pierces) were considered for cost-per-hour of overhead and labor, the cross-over point of a 450Amp plasma vs. an oxy-fuel torch was found to be just a little less than 3” thick. However, if the plasma speed was doubled, the results were different. 

Conclusion

For deciding whether a part should use a burning machine or a plasma cutter:

• Use plasma for all instances that have a production piercing capacity of 2 inches thickness.
• Use oxy-fuel for  those materials that can be chain cut or are more than 1 inch thick (with 1 or 2 pierces), and are capable of being cut with a minimum of 4 oxy-fuel torches. Else, use plasma.

Hope this helps you find answers to the age old question. Do post your logic or comments speaking of your own experiences.

Read More

Welding Efficiency Analysis Program from Red-d-Arc

Are you worried about hidden costs eating into your bottom line figures? The smartly conceived Welding Efficiency Analysis program by Red-d-Arc provides a comprehensive analysis of your welding operations along with insightful comparisons with your peers. Get an estimate of your position in the industry with their free Welding Efficiency Analysis services and reach higher levels of efficiency—the right way.

Metal Fabrication

With years of experience in handling the most formidable problems addressing the welding industry, Red-d-Arc goes a long way in helping customers figure out and reign in the various costs that negatively impact the returns on their welding operations. This program helps in:

• A thorough analysis of welding processes including the comparative usage of various consumables.
• Offering a comparison of how your operations compare with that of peers and other bench marked operations of the industry.
• Prioritizing and quantifying improvement opportunities and so forth.

Unleash and Eliminate the Hidden Costs of Welding Class

Welding Efficiency Analysis services show that most welding operations end up striking an arc (actually welding) merely 9 minutes in each hour. This results in most operations wasting a large quantity of the MIG consumables and shielding gas purchased by them. Red-d-Arc unleashes these hidden costs and helps fabricators and manufacturers gain awareness about their operational problems and key welding metrics.

Way Forward

So, what are you waiting for? Just invest three-and-a-half days of your time in the Welding Efficiency Analysis program and Red-d-Arc pays you back many times over. Specifically conceptualized and programmed for department heads, business owners, shop foremen, as well as those presiding as decision makers, the modules of this program succeed in getting at least 20 percent more from your operating costs, along with bringing about much required improvements in your overall performance and quality of operations.

Read More